Skip to content

Rank

68

5 places down No. 63 last week

Regulatory / CompetitionGovernment power & public lawGovernment and public law

Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha

Does federal law require mandatory detention without bond for long-present immigrants?

Rank, last 10 weeks Best No. 36 · lowest No. 68
No. 110203040506070 36384344456368
At stake
Injunctive relief
Score
47.4Out of 100
Latest event
Oct 16, 20265 weeks ago
Next step
Not scheduledNothing dated on the record yet
Commenced
20264 mo ago
Court
U.S. Supreme Court26-104

Stage

Appeal. An appellate court is reviewing a decision. How cases are placed

  1. Filed
  2. Pre-trial
  3. Trial
  4. Decision
  5. AppealNow
  6. Enforcement

Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da Cunha, a Brazilian national detained by U.S. immigration authorities in 2025, argues in habeas proceedings that federal law does not require his detention without a bond hearing. The district court and the Second Circuit ruled for him, and the U.S. Supreme Court granted the government’s cert petition on October 1, 2026. The government’s opening brief is due November 30, 2026, and Barbosa da Cunha’s brief is due January 13, 2027.

Latest development Oct 16, 2026

On October 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court granted the parties’ consented request to extend the merits briefing schedule. The joint appendix and the government’s opening brief are now due November 30, 2026, and Barbosa da Cunha’s brief is due January 13, 2027.

Why it matters

The U.S. Supreme Court will decide whether the executive may detain, without individualized bond hearings, noncitizens who entered without being admitted and have lived in the United States for years. The answer affects large numbers of people in immigration proceedings and dozens of related habeas and class cases.

Background

Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da Cunha is a Brazilian national who entered the United States around 2004 or 2005. He later built a family, home, and business in New York. The Trump administration adopted a new policy reading 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) to require mandatory detention without bond for noncitizens present in the country without formal admission. In September 2025, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) detained him, and an immigration judge denied him a bond hearing on the basis of that policy.

Barbosa da Cunha filed a habeas petition, later transferred to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, and amended it on October 3, 2025. He is represented by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU), and the Law Office of Paul O’Dwyer PC. He argued that the mandatory-detention provision applies only to noncitizens arriving at the border or ports of entry, not to those who have lived in the interior for years. On November 25, 2025, the court ruled in his favor and ordered the government to provide a bond hearing. The government appealed.

On April 28, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed. It held that mandatory detention under § 1225(b)(2)(A) is limited to noncitizens “seeking admission.” Long-present interior entrants instead fall under the discretionary bond framework of 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a). The ruling conflicted with decisions from other circuits that had adopted the government’s broader reading, creating a circuit split. On July 22, 2026, the Solicitor General petitioned for a writ of certiorari, and Barbosa da Cunha’s counsel filed a response opposing review on September 4, 2026.

On October 1, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court granted review. It agreed to decide whether the statute mandates detention pending removal proceedings for noncitizens who are present in the United States without having been admitted. Dozens of related habeas and class proceedings around the country raise the same question. News reports indicate that two circuits have sided with the government and several others, including the Second Circuit, have ruled against the policy.

On October 16, 2026, the Solicitor General’s office, with the consent of all parties, asked the Supreme Court under Rule 30.4 to extend the merits briefing schedule. The government’s opening brief was then due November 16, 2026. The Court granted the request the same day. The joint appendix and the government’s opening brief are now due November 30, 2026, and Barbosa da Cunha’s brief is due January 13, 2027. No oral argument date has been set.

Timeline 10 events

  1. Order
    Supreme Court grants extended merits briefing schedule

    The Court granted the parties’ consented request. The government’s brief and the joint appendix are now due November 30, 2026, and Barbosa da Cunha’s brief is due January 13, 2027.

    Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha (26-104)

  2. Order
    Government seeks consented extension of merits briefing schedule

    The Solicitor General’s office asked the Supreme Court under Rule 30.4 to extend the schedule, with the consent of all parties. The government’s opening brief was then due November 16, 2026.

    U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Solicitor General extension letterRhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha (26-104)No. 26-104 — Supreme Court Petition Tracker

  3. Order
    Supreme Court grants certiorari

    The Supreme Court agreed to hear the case in its October 2026 term to resolve the circuit split over the scope of mandatory immigration detention.

    Order List: 609 U.S., October 1, 2026ACLU Comment on Supreme Court Agreeing to Hear Challenge Over Trump Mandatory Detention Policy

  4. Filing
    Barbosa da Cunha files response opposing certiorari

    Docket for 26-104

  5. Filing
    Solicitor General petitions for certiorari

    The government, represented by Solicitor General D. John Sauer, asked the Supreme Court to review the Second Circuit’s decision.

    Office of the Solicitor General: Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha

  6. Judgment
    Second Circuit affirms ruling against mandatory detention policy

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit held that § 1225(b)(2)(A) mandatory detention applies only to noncitizens seeking admission, not to long-present interior entrants like Barbosa da Cunha.

    Cunha v. Freden, No. 25-3141 (2d Cir. 2026)Federal Appeals Court Rules Against Trump Administration's New Mandatory Detention Policy

  7. Filing
    ACLU, NYCLU, and co-counsel sue over detention policy

    The ACLU, NYCLU, and the Law Office of Paul O’Dwyer PC filed suit challenging the administration’s policy of subjecting large numbers of immigrants to mandatory detention without bond hearings.

    Cunha v. Freden

  8. Judgment
    District court grants habeas relief

    The U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York ruled that Barbosa da Cunha was not subject to mandatory detention. It ordered the government to provide a bond hearing.

    Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha (petition for writ of certiorari)

  9. Filing
    Barbosa da Cunha files amended habeas petition

    Barbosa da Cunha challenged the government’s mandatory-detention interpretation of 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A).

    Answering Brief, Cunha v. Freden (2d Cir.)

  10. Other
    DHS detains Barbosa da Cunha without bond

    The Department of Homeland Security placed Barbosa da Cunha in removal proceedings and an immigration judge found him subject to mandatory detention without a bond hearing.

    Appeals Court Rejects Trump Admin's Mandatory Detention Policy for Immigrants

Experimental AI forecast

How it is made

How will the U.S. Supreme Court resolve Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha on the scope of mandatory detention under § 1225(b)(2)(A)?

  • Court upholds government’s reading56%
  • Court affirms Second Circuit29%
  • Vacated and remanded on narrower ground8%
  • Dismissed as improvident or moot4%
  • Still pending on July 31, 20273%
Resolves by
Jul 31, 2027in 8 months
Record confidence
Medium

The Supreme Court is more likely than not to adopt the government’s reading of § 1225(b)(2)(A), at 56%, with a decision expected by late June 2027. The statute’s definition of applicants for admission gives the government a strong textual argument, and the Court reverses most judgments it reviews.

How it resolves. Resolved by the Supreme Court’s disposition in No. 26-104 as shown on the Court’s docket or in its opinion. Reversal adopting the government’s reading that § 1225(b)(2)(A) mandates detention for noncitizens present without admission counts as the government prevailing. Affirmance counts as Barbosa da Cunha prevailing. Vacatur and remand without adopting either reading counts as mixed. Dismissal as improvidently granted or as moot counts as dismissed. No decision by July 31, 2027, counts as still pending.

Reasoning

Starting point. U.S. Supreme Court merits cases granted on a Solicitor General petition to resolve a circuit split on a federal statute: The Court reverses or vacates roughly 70% of the lower-court judgments it reviews. Government petitions granted at the SG’s request succeed at a somewhat higher rate.

The starting point is the roughly 70% rate at which the Court reverses or vacates the judgments it reviews, which is higher when the Solicitor General is the petitioner. The government’s case rests on statutory text that treats noncitizens present without admission as applicants for admission. Barbosa da Cunha’s strongest answer is structural. Section 1226(a) has long governed interior arrests with bond, and later amendments to § 1226(c) appear to assume that entrants without admission fall under § 1226. A majority of circuits reportedly agreed with him, which keeps affirmance a real possibility at 29%. A narrower vacatur, for example on remedy or the reach of bond procedures, is a modest alternative. Mootness risk is low because the government sought review and the issue recurs across dozens of habeas and class cases. Briefing runs through January 13, 2027, plus a reply, so argument in early 2027 and a decision by late June 2027 are expected. That makes a still-pending result unlikely. No development since the October 21, 2026, forecast changes the analysis, so the numbers are unchanged.

Statutory definition of applicant for admission favors government · Structure of § 1226 and later amendments support Barbosa da Cunha · High Supreme Court reversal rate on SG petitions · Circuit split with most circuits rejecting the policy · Briefing schedule points to decision by June 2027

Generated automatically by Claude Opus 5.5 on Nov 4, 2026 from this case’s record on this site, and published without editorial review. The probabilities are the model’s judgment, not measured frequencies, and they are scored publicly as cases resolve. Not legal or investment advice. How the forecasts are made